★★ | New York Times Critic’s Pick
by Ryan Sutton

Favorite NJ Restaurants of 2026

Critic’s Pick, New Jersey Monthly

“#1 Upside Down Pie”

NEW JERSEY’S 101 BEST PIZZAS RANKED, FOR 2025 NJ.COM
-Peter Genovese and Jeremy Schneider

“N.J.’s best new pizzeria serves incredible
‘New York square pies.’ We’ll allow it.”

-Jeremy Schneider, NJ.com

“Corner Slice may be the single best slice of pizza in New York...
They're elevating the New York pizza slice in a way that no one else has”

-Ed Levine, Serious Eats

“...the best new pizzeria in New York...”

-Ryan Sutton, Eater New York

“...astonishingly good, high-quality squares…” 

-Food & Wine Magazine